Frequently Asked Questions

Are you open?

Our hours are Monday - Tuesday: 12 - 7 PM, Wednesday - Friday: 12 - 8 PM, Saturday: 11AM - 8 PM, Sunday: 12 - 6 PM. We are closed Thanksgiving and Christmas Day. We may have shorter hours on other holidays.

Do you buy comics?

Maybe! It depends on rarity, condition, and sellability. The owner of the store can take a look at collections during business hours everyday of the week except for Tuesdays and Fridays. Always call us at (414) 328-4651 ahead of time to make sure the buyer is in.

Do you buy [thing that isn’t comic books]?

No, we are only interested in purchasing comic books at this time.

Do you buy [different thing that isn’t comics books]?

No, we are only interested in purchasing comic books at this time.

Do you do pre-orders for comics?

Yes! Please check out our comic subscription page for full details.

Can I pre-order trading cards?

No, we do not. Our TCG/CCG products (Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic the Gathering, etc) are sold on a first-come, first-served basis. We also reserve the right to restrict the quantity of any product sold for any reason.

Are you hiring?

When a position becomes available, we post about it in-store and you can pick up an application. If you’re interested in working at Lost World, please visit us frequently.

Can I bring my class/field trip/family/ etc?

Of course! If you are planning on bringing in a group of 10 or more children or students, we appreciate a call or email ahead of time so we can anticipate your visit. Any disruptive behavior (ex running, yelling) will not be tolerated from any of our customers.

What is your return policy?

Returns are accepted within 10 days of the item's purchase date, unopened and in its original condition. All sales are final on clearance/sale items. Back issues valued $10 or more are not returnable. Lost World of Wonders reserves the right to limit the quantaties of any product sold or returned for any reason.

Do you still have a cat?

Unfortunately, Boo passed away a couple years ago. She was over 20 years old! If you listen closely, they say you can still hear her crawling around in the ceiling…

Do you do donations?

Please email or call the store with any donation requests. We have donated to schools, libraries, youth clubs, community organizations, and other non-profit organizations in the past.

If you have any questions not answered here, please give us a call at (414) 328-4651, email us at store@lostwonders.com or drop by the store



Milwaukee's Pop Culture Destination